home
 
 

 
Detailed Comments on #13-15 & #20-22 & #34-35

Does the Charge Field Travel in Conducting Wire?
*_#13a says Free electrons travel at high speed in a conducting wire, or any conductor,
- This contradicts #20-22, which says
_20 If you read the page at Wiki on electrical circuits, you get the impression that electrons travel through the circuit, creating the energy transfer.
_21 Sefton shows us that is false, and I have nothing to say against him. His argument in that regard is convincing.
*_22 The electrons are simply moving too slow.
- I conclude that #13a is wrong.
- #22 seems Important for the Battery Circuit paper model.

*_13a Free electrons travel at high speed in a conducting wire, or any conductor,
*_13b because the B-field is moving in only one direction in that substance.
*_14 The B-field acts as a river, moving the electrons along by direct contact.
*_15 This B-field river can be created in any number of ways, either by having lots of radiating particles at one end of the wire and few or none at the other, or by directionalizing the B-field through the shape of the molecules in the substance.
- #13b-15 seem Important to rule out, because they seem to contradict the Batter Circuit paper. MM's current view should be requested.

Photon Flow in Wire or Not?
#15 contradicts #34-35 as follows.
*_15 This B-field river can be created in any number of ways, either by having lots of radiating particles at one end of the wire and few or none at the other, or by directionalizing the B-field through the shape of the molecules in the substance.
_34 Now, if we extend wires to the bulb, we haven't provided the path to the bulb that the photons must take, since the photons need no path of that kind.
*_35 What we have done is prime the field, like what happens in wireless transmission.
- #15 & #35 seem Important to clarify.
 


↑ UP Powered by Quick Disclosure Lite
© 2010~2021 SCS-INC.US
UP ↑